Leadership Comparison and Critique Essay - 3860 Words

Leader Comparison and Critique: Steve Jobs Indra Nooyi Lauren Murphy GBA 500 Centenary College In 1978, J.M. Burns defined successful leaders as being transformational rather than transactional. Burns described the transformational leader as having recognized the organization as a complex system in a chaotic environment. The leader has also responded to complexity by being aware of change. The transformational leader has established a shared vision and inspired the organization to learn and evolve in response to change. Transformational leaders have driven radical change, trading short-term stability for long-term survival. In 2007, Kouzes and Posner refined Burn’s work by breaking down the transformational leader’s†¦show more content†¦Ã¢â‚¬Å"Leaders demonstrate their intense commitment to the values they espouse by setting an example. It’s how they earn and sustain credibility over time. Setting the Example is all about execution and action. It’s all about doing what you say. Leaders who are seen as practicing what they preach are more ef fective than those leaders who don’t.† (Kouzes Posner, 94) As successful as Steve Jobs appears to be, there are some leadership qualities that need to be improved. One such behavior would be â€Å"model the way† (Kouzes Posner, 45) Steve Jobs has not established principles concerning the way people should be treated, nor does Jobs create standards of excellence as a leadership example for others to follow. In fact, this leader has been known to â€Å"scream at employees to the point of hyperventilation.† (Pomiewozik, 2000) This leader has also been guilty of failing to follow through on promises and commitments. As an employer, Jobs was obligated to compensate employees for work as agreed upon in the job contract. That obligation to compensate employees was not followed through when Jobs fired a P.R. consultant and refused to pay the employee for completed work. (Pomiewozik, 2000) The demeaning attitude of this leader should not serve as an example f or employees. On one occasion Steve Jobs played a cruel joke on an employee by pretending to offer the employee a position as Apple C.E.O. (Pomiewozik, 2000) â€Å"Values are empowering†¦.Values motivate.† (Kouzes Posner,Show MoreRelatedI Am As A Teacher873 Words   |  4 Pagesin the Spring semester. The process of developing this syllabus began with my initial write-up and peer critique. I was able to change several aspects of my approach and refine how I would develop my syllabus. After I made changes and implemented my peers critiques I spent my time initially with the resources that I wanted to use and worked to really get my mind around leadership and how I should approach an introductory course geared towards teaching this topic. I then worked to see howRead MoreEssay on Emotional Intelligence in Leadership1548 Words   |  7 Pages The premise of emotional intelligence in leadership is that emotional intelligence should be the premise of leadership. Before tasks, followers, goals and styles can be defined or critiqued, the leader’s emotional intelligence must first be assessed (Goleman, Boyatzis McKee, 2002, pg 5). Emotional intelligence then becomes the predictor of how effectively the leader will be able to lead in any given situation, set of tasks or followers. In this paper, the author will compare this premiseRead MoreA Critical Analysis Of Citizen Life In Platos The Republic1552 Words   |  7 Pagesclass hierarchies, yet the Philosopher King and the tyrant are extreme version of this similar application of monolithic leadership. The experiences of the worker/producer will provide a critique on the similar nature of singular leadership under these highly divisive living conditions. In essence, a comparison analysis of aristocracy and tyranny will be examined through a critique of the life of t he citizen in Plato’s The Republic. The role of the aristocracy in Socrates’ â€Å"just city† is defined throughRead MoreEssay on Empirical Literature Article Review of Leadership Ethics1195 Words   |  5 PagesArticle Review of Leadership Ethics Lillie Johnson LDR 800, Ethical Dilemmas and Stewardship June 4, 2013 Empirical Literature Article Review of Leadership Ethics The opportunity to evaluate original research serves as one of the many foundations to both scholarly writing and research (Grand Canyon University, 2013). Therefore, to enhance this process I will critique empirical research articles for the purpose of demonstrating the effectiveness in understanding leadership ethics. So, usingRead MoreOrganizational Behavior And Leadership Analysis Essay924 Words   |  4 PagesOrganizational Behavior and Leadership Analysis Introduction Leadership and organizational behavior are structured elements of life that give meaning to factors such as motivation and effort. Leadership is not easily understood and as such it is taken to mean different things by different people. However, leadership and effective organizational behavior all lead to achieving the same results and ensuring that employee effort does not go unrecognized. Leadership Comparisons Former Coach Bobby KnightRead MoreLeaders Must Be Very Keen On Change Management1565 Words   |  7 Pageslive team. The leader will be shown how to introduce the change and implement it with a successful team. They will be on all interaction between team members and leadership on this change and will be the upfront manager for team questions and alignment. Leadership Skill Development From the required leadership skills I am now going to explain how the program will develop those skills. 1) Managing People – We are going to incorporate the following skills development trainingRead MoreEssay on Controlling Organized Crime1564 Words   |  7 PagesControlling Organized Crime In this paper, I will identify the problems presented and the various relationships established by organized crime. I will also describe the legal limitations associated with combating organized crime, and include a critique of major federal laws and strategies that support this effort. Lastly, I will suggest a solution to control organized crime by discussing and evaluating the effectiveness of organized crime prosecutions. The organized crime legal definitionRead MoreColor Acts As A Symbolic Foundation For The Film1163 Words   |  5 Pagesbe saved? The intersection of symbolism and theme in Wall-E is rooted in social commentary, as the film critiques the corporate consumer culture epitomized by BnL leadership and control. As previously discussed, these symbols powerfully establish blame in the film’s introduction. Later, it is discovered that BnL’s best, most loyal consumers have been skyrocketed into space where this critique gains greater momentum in predicting the future of humanity if this ecological suicide path continues toRead MoreThe Registered Nurse Is Responsible For Providing Comprehensive And Effective Nursing Care1221 Words   |  5 Pagesand medical record, and keeping a record of the inventory and supplies needed, among other administrative functions. NYP Weill Cornell is characterized by its transformational leadership philosophy. Transformational leadership has benefits such as†¦. This type of leadership needs to be coupled with transactional leadership in order to optimize their results (Marquiz Huston, 2014). This unit has been operating with a shared governance model which we will be discussing later on in section III of thisRead MoreCritique of the Gifted and Talented Evaluation Scales1469 Words   |  6 Pagesstudents. Section four, five, and six all further detail the raw score of the student by converting the raw score into percentiles, etc. Once the scores are completed they can be assessed against the individual scales. Based on the student’s scores, a comparison is made against the ranging standard scale to estimate the likelihood of giftedness and talentedness of the student (Jarosewich, Pfeiffer, Morris, 2002). Raw scores are converted into percentiles since they have little clinical value. They are